Book Review: "George Frisbie Hoar and the Half-Breed Republicans" by Richard E. Welch, Jr.
Contemporary teachings about the Stalwart vs. Half-Breed feuds of the 1870s and 1880s usually contain glaring errors as they attempt to generalize the big picture. The portrayal of the Half-Breeds during the presidency of Rutherford B. Hayes as a clique of supporters of James G. Blaine is what standard textbooks provide, though it is anything but accurate. The historical record says something different, however. In "George Frisbie Hoar and the Half-Breed Republicans," Richard E. Welch, Jr., in part emphasizes the true characteristics of the Half-Breeds, in addition to their original comprisal among Republican Party ranks. He summarizes it well in p. 91: By the middle of the Hayes’s administration certain politicians were already representative of the goals and prejudices of Half-Breed Republicanism. Not James G. Blaine—who at this point represented a particular wing of the Stalwarts and became a Half-Breed only with the campaign of 1880—but men like Hayes, Hoar, George Edmund...